@Octodemon’s Dino Escape - S tier Reason: Amazing game has great art and decent gameplay
@PixelDoodle’s Bloxdog Adventure - D tier Reason: The Gameplay isn’t great and there is a lot of bugs
More coming soon
13 Likes
S? I’d give that game a B or C at most. There are a few bugs and the game was rushed. But thanks for the S anyways!
5 Likes
2nd Opinion!
Octodemon’s “FPS Game Makecode One” ~ B+
Unfortunately, Futureknight was incorrect, for Dino Escape was not Octodemon’s first game, although it was amazing! As for the reason, FPS Game demonstrates a keen understanding on Makecode code and use of extensions along with some competent art! A well introduction!
PixelDoodle’s “Bloxdog Adventure” ~ C-
This game is a good start into the Makecode Forums, showing an interest in making games, which can be said about most. Bloxdog contains bugs, and issues with gameplay, but is expected from a beginner game. This game demonstrates a basic understanding on how extensions work, and how to explain a story!
More coming soon~!
7 Likes
RATE the icicle adveture demo! ANd goombas leap
5 Likes
@InvalidProject’s tower of the twins B tier - not bad story and art but gameplay is okay
6 Likes
@goldtopaz’s hyper the dragon - F TIER
I am sorry @goldtopaz but your game’s gameplay is bad, the art is over saturated, the controls are bad. The objective is unclear. and the game crashes a lot
5 Likes
Ooo! I like this! Some nice game critique, and to see how far these users have come!
6 Likes
2nd Opinion!
InvalidProject’s “Tower of the Twins” ~ A-
This answerr may vary considering I am reviewing my own game. The game is made with a clear idea and thought out gameplay. Although it can seema bit repetitive at times, it demonstrates a knowledge on extensions on tilemaps.
GoldTopaz’s “Hyper the Dragon” ~ S-
For a first game, the amount delivered is huge! Art and story can be touched on but are nonetheless outstanding! With a clear passion and love for coding, Hyper stands out amongst the others listed here.
More coming soon~!
8 Likes
Yup that was my first “game” posted on the forums. It wasn’t really meant to be a game, (just a template of some sort) Thanks for the B+!
6 Likes
Owie ouch
4 Likes
…you should give him a bit more credit! It’s really not that bad, I think you overdid it. I’d give it a B-. A lot of work was put into it obviously. It just didn’t go together quite right. The colour scheme doesn’t really work very well, appears rather like TV static.
I just recommend making the main character smaller, and adding more clumped pixels rather than a static look. Also, try colour schemes for enemies and gimmicks! By that I mean make your enemies and obstacles certain colours SOLELY based on that category. Do all that and it’ll be a B+ or A- for sure.
That’s another small mistake you made, future. You didn’t give feedback! You just right off the bat said the game is bad, full stop, no “how to get better”, NOTHING.
But for a first game, that is REALLY IMPRESSIVE. Your first game is never perfect.
Just stepped in cuz in my eyes it felt a bit pointed.
Bye 
10 Likes
Based imo 
.
7 Likes
@Future_Knight do makecode forums 1
2 Likes
@Blobbey 's Cash Clicker C tier
It is okay but it is good. The idea @blobbey has is good. But the execution the way it was programmed wasn’t the greatest
1 Like
it is for the first games users made
2 Likes
Could you do mine?
2 Likes
Ehe… not my first game.
5 Likes
Could you do Cookie Clicker But Budget
3 Likes
do my slopes project please lol
2 Likes
oh ok
2 Likes