Why are people saying that makecode is a knockoff of scratch

buddy Makecode has repeat it doesn’t have repeat until {} but you can just use repeat until <not>{}

and It has a while loop

3 Likes

I mean its a little bit harder

4 Likes

I guess buts that’s a lot more code

1 Like

there’s no for loop!!

1 Like

TRAITO-

/just kidding don’t eat me I’ll give you some


4 Likes

Aw man images don’t blur

4 Likes

Where’s the value of element of array and the index from 0 - x

Where’s on game update and in game update tree every x ms

3 Likes

What y u say dat

1 Like

Wouldn’t On Game Update just be a forever loop?

And you can just do this for the game update X ms:

Also, for the element of the array, you could just use a list block and do this:

4 Likes

forever loops have micro pauses between frames while game update runs every frrame

6 Likes

Ok nevermind I take back everything I said Makecode and Scratch are now on the same level

4 Likes

(sorry I’m late) I think you can spoiler images like this?

3 Likes

Imagine it more like Two kids wanted to complete the same assignment and both got a good grade. They didn’t necessarily Copy of Eachother but they both did the same homework.

3 Likes

Oh I forgot so what I mean is scratch was released in 2007 like you stated before but MakeCode released to general availability(GA) in 2020

3 Likes

Idea- there is a glitch that if you try to use a tile map over as a reference any changes are also applied to original.

1 Like

Also make copy paste in images work for mobile people cause if you don’t want to use advanced animations then it’s annoying from the little time I spent

I feel like most people say that it is a ripoff because Scratch is most commonly used in younger grades, therefore giving them the Scratch experience first, before Makecode. Makecode I would assume (please fact check), is used in more secondary schools.

Sure, Makecode and Scratch are both very similar considering the fact that they have block coding, that does not mean that Makecode is a knockoff of Scratch.

This is just my opinion though, I do prefer Makecode so I may be a little bit biased so yeah.

1 Like

I hate it when people at my school spam that scratch is better like its as obvious as the sky being blue!

I respect their opinions and all but they are just that, opinions!

1 Like

The “ripoff” label mostly comes from surface similarity: drag-and-drop blocks, stage-like canvases, and classroom use. But similar UI conventions aren’t the same as copying; block languages share a common lineage, and MakeCode’s center of gravity is hardware and microcontroller projects, while Scratch is broader creative computing. The point about younger students meeting Scratch first is plausible too—people often judge MakeCode against that first template. Calling it a knockoff is more a lazy comparison than an accurate one.

1 Like

This implies you say scratch is better and is an obvious fact, but we are a MAKECODE forum not a SCRATCH forum … do whatever you want with that information.